Sunday 12 December 2021

Analysis of avalanche accident Venet on 11.12.2021

 Course of events and Avalanche facts


Today (12.12) we were at the scene of the accident together with the Alpine Police and other experts. The research of the Alpine Police resulted in the following course of events:

Six youths descended three times orographically left of the subsequent avalanche, quite near the secured ski slope in successively flatter backcountry terrain. During their fourth descent just before 12:00 they traversed a very steep north-facing slope. In the middle of very steep to extremely steep terrain, they came to a halt, one after another. When the last two persons of this group skied to the meeting spot, a slab avalanche triggered above them. All of them were caught in the avalanche. While one person managed to ski (orographically right) out of the avalanche, the others were swept along. Four of them were buried partially, one of them totally.

The avalanche was observed by other winter sports enthusiasts. They professionally alarmed the authorities without delay and immediately initiated a search for the buried skiers.

Two of the partially buried persons suffered injuries and were flown to the Zams hospital. The totally buried person was found after one and a half hours of intense search, lifeless.

The avalanche was 280m long, 70m wide and had an average fracture depth of about 50cm (maximum 140cm). The fracture zone was at 2140m. The slope had a 40° steepness gradient (extremely steep) and faced north.



Übersichtsbild vom 11.12.2021: Der Pfeil symbolisiert die Einfahrtsspur, das Rechteck den ungefähren Sammelpunkt, der Kreis den Auffindepunkt des tödlich Verunglückten. Die blau dargestellte Lawine löste sich nach diesem Lawinenabgang im Rahmen der Rettungsaktion durch Fernauslösung.
Overview on 11.12.2021. Arrow points to entry track; square the approximate meeting spot; circle the spot where the victim was found. Blue-marked zone is an avalanche triggered after this avalanche (by remote triggering) while the rescue was being conducted.

   

Weiteres Überblicksbild
An additional Alpine Police overview on 11.12.2021



Im Anrissgebiet der Lawine. Man erkennt links oben einen Teil des Lawinenanrisses. Zudem lässt sich die Steilheit des Geländes erahnen. (Foto:12.12.2021)
Fracture zone of the avalanche. Visible at upper left, a part of the avalanche fracture. The steepness of the slope is also evident. (photo: 12.12.2021)



Am Lawinenanriss. Bruch bis in bodennahe Schichten. Rechts zudem eine gering mächtige, kürzlich gebildete Triebschneeauflage zu erkennen. (Foto: 12.12.2021)
At the fracture, which extended to ground-level layers. Right, a shallow, recently formed snowdrift accumulation. (photo: 12.12.2021)



Bei der kleinen Lärche wurde der getötete Jugendliche aufgefunden (Foto: 12.12.2021)
Next to the small larch tree the lifeless youth was found. (photo: 12.12.2021)



Snowpack analysis


Our snowpack analysis confirmed a combination of snowdrift problem and persistent weak layer which we presumed was the cause (see yesterday’s blog). The persistent weak layer had a thoroughgoing, often pronounced weak streak of loose, faceted crystals which caused the magnitude of the release. The relevant weak layers formed during a period of beautiful weather in November.

What was striking - and this was also demonstrated in snowpack analysis in other parts of the land - was that where the snow was shallow, the weak layers were more pronounced and more prone to triggering than where the snow was deep. In the shallow-snow zones, far less additional loading is necessary to unleash an avalanche.


Profil an einem schneearmen Bereich orographisch links des Lawinenanrisses. Ein "Krusten-Sandwich" mit dazwischen liegenden, lockeren Schichten. Darüber ein mitunter vom Wind geprägtes Schneepaket. (Foto: 12.12.2021)
Profile of a shallow-snow zone orographically left of the avalanche fracture. A crust-sandwich with loose layers in between. On top, a snow mass showing wind impact. (photo: 12.12.2021)



Das zu obigem Bild gehörige Profil. Der Pfeil zeigt die schwache Schicht aus kantigen Kristallen, die mitunter sehr leicht zu stören war.
Snow-profile for the above photo. Arrow points to the weak layer of faceted crystals which was extremely easy to trigger.


Schneeprofil an einer schneereicheren Stelle. Oberflächennahe Triebschneepakete lagern auf weicheren Schichten. Bodennahe schwache Schichten aus kantigen Kristallen haben sich hier deutlich schwerer stören lassen. (Foto: 12.12.2021)
Snow profile at a spot where the snow is deeper. Superficial snowdrift masses deposited atop softer layers. At ground level, weak layers of faceted crystals are far more difficult to trigger here. (photo: 12.12.2021)


Das zu obigem Foto dazugehörige Schneeprofil: Der Pfeil zeigt auf die für den Lawinenabgang bedeutsame Schwachschicht. Das Profil wurde orographisch links der Lawinenbahn in etwa in Höhe des Sammelpunktes der Jugendlichen an einer schneereichen Stelle gegraben.
Snow profile for the above photo. Arrow points to the significant weak layer for this avalanche. The profile was dug orographically left of the avalanche path at the altitude of the meeting spot of the youths in a spot where the snow was deep.


THE BOTTOM LINE:

Slab avalanches can still be triggered in weak layers, particularly in spots where the snow is shallow and in transition zones from shallow to deep snow. Consolidation of these layers is currently taking place only very slowly. In the immediate future, nothing will change in this complex and difficult-to-assess avalanche situation above the timberline.